Fantastic Fest 2012: ‘American Mary’ steeped in pulp and hardcore imagery and fetishistic gore

American Mary
Directed by Jen and Sylvia Soska
Written by Jen and Sylvia Soska
2012, Canada

Steeped in pulp and hardcore imagery, horror allusions, and fetishistic gore, American Mary is a film that has emphatic reverence for its form. And as a collection of horror set pieces and bizarre characters, it is a success. Unfortunately, it’s not so successful as a cohesive and meaningful film.

Mary Mason (Katharine Isabelle) is a young med student enrolled in a surgery residency. She’s fantastic at what she does, but in great financial and academic distress. When putting in a resume at the local strip-joint, she’s recruited to stitch up a gunshot victim in the backroom. She’s rewarded handsomely, and almost immediately contacted for some unusual surgical services. And thus she enters the seedy world of body modification. Katharine Isabelle is best-known in the horror community as the titular character of Ginger Snaps. She’s rightly beloved for that role, and here she performs marvelously. Her Mary Mason can be mercilessly sexy and cool, but Isabelle finds the intelligent, morally confounded girl within, and her performance deserves to be featured in a far better picture.

There’s no doubting the Soska sisters’ (aka The Twisted Twins of Dead Hooker in the Trunk fame) enthusiasm and imagination. And for the first third, American Mary threatens to turn into something really special–a thoughtful and refreshing revival grindhouse pic. All the elements are here. There’s the spurned, angry protagonist with a as much smarts as sexy. There’s a collection of fascinating freaks–the most sympathetic being Beatress (Tristan Risk), a modded-out woman who looks and talks like Betty Boop. And there’s a slick and confident aesthetic that makes the film eminently watchable. But the directors seem so caught up in delivering iconic sequences that they forget to concentrate on intelligible pacing and recognizable behavior.

Mary’s journey is meandering and unfocused. What appears at first to be a simple and straightforward vengeance mission quickly diffuses into a series of disconnected sequences with no forward momentum. The established villains are nowhere to be seen in the back-half of the film, with the Soskas instead introducing disparate and irrelevant elements (including their own useless cameo) to kill time before the unearned bloody conclusion. If you’re a fan of punk horror filmmaking, this is an enjoyable film–and especially rewarding for its central performance and sassy ‘tude–but Mary is ultimately an unfulfilled promise.

–Emmet Duff

Fantastic Fest runs September 20th – September 27th.

Previous articleSons of Anarchy, Ep. 5.03, “Laying Pipe”: Finding the hidden advantage
Next articleSketchy Episode 34 – ‘Highschool of the Dead (学園黙示録)’
Emmet Duff is a small town Ohioan reborn as an Austin, TX based artist and writer. He spent his youth either reading or watching movies, which is probably why he feels compelled to watch movies and then write words about them. In 2009, he graduated from Kenyon College with a double degree in Psychology and Studio Art and has yet to capitalize on that deadly combination.  Once a kindly and humble Midwesterner, Emmet now eats a Tex Mex breakfast, sports a ten gallon hat, and refuses to be messed with. As an artist, Emmet enjoys photographing things, building things, and photographing things that he builds.  Though his writing extends beyond cinema and criticism, he started his illustrious film writing career working for his older, very talented, brother in Sydney, Australia.  Emmet has a enthusiastic love for all kinds of films and would be hard pressed to name a favorite filmmaker.  But one time he spent a few days rewatching all of David Cronenberg’s films in a row.  And he didn’t hate it.