Greatest TV Pilots: The Dick Van Dyke Show’s “The Sick Boy and the Sitter” remains an effective, entertaining opener

The Dick Van Dyke Show title card

The Dick Van Dyke Show title card

The Dick Van Dyke Show, “The Sick Boy and the Sitter”
Written by Carl Reiner
Directed by Sheldon Leonard
Aired on October 3rd, 1961 on CBS

The Dick Van Dyke Show is one of the most enduring sitcoms of television history. While most series fall from recognition shortly after their finales, it remains a staple of Best Comedy lists to this day. The premise is very straightforward- Dick Van Dyke stars as Rob Petrie, a comedy writer at the fictional The Alan Brady Show. He’s married to Laura, played by Mary Tyler Moore, and the two have a son, Ritchie, and live in New Rochelle. We follow Rob at home and at work, where he often shares scenes with fellow writers Buddy Sorrell (Morey Amsterdam) and Sally Rogers (Rose Marie) and occasionally with their straight-man producer, Mel Cooley, played by Richard Deacon.

The pilot opens simply. Laura’s in the kitchen cooking when Ritchie comes home from his friend Emily’s house. Emily’s come down with a fever and when Ritchie turns down his normal afternoon snack of milk and a chocolate cupcake, Laura’s worried. It’s an interesting way to open the series, one that immediately places importance on Mary Tyler Moore and the family aspect of the premise. In the original pilot, which starred Carl Reiner, the first scene followed Rob as he drove to work in New York and then interacted with his coworkers. CBS wanted the leads recast, which led to a new pilot and a new approach. By letting us get to know Laura first before focusing on Rob, the central relationship has parity; she’s not just Mrs. Rob.

Dick Van Dyke and Mary Tyler Moore in The Dick Van Dyke Show pilot, The Sick Boy and the Sitter

The opening scene also succeeds in getting us to like Ritchie. Though he’s in danger of crossing over from cute to annoying or precocious, Reiner and Leonard make him feel like enough of a real kid to avoid that, and Larry Mathews’ energy is infectious. After our introduction to the Petrie house, we cut to Rob at work and meet the writing staff of The Alan Brady Show. The writers have an easy chemistry with each other and this is obviously a world Reiner knows very well; he based the series on his experiences writing for Your Show of Shows. This was one of the very first examples of a TV show featuring a show-within-a-show, and yet it still plays well to an audience very familiar with this setting. Reiner treats his audience intelligently, letting them fill in the gaps and not over-explaining the specifics of how being a comedy writer works.

The rest of the pilot centers on very familiar elements. Rob wants to go to a work party downtown while Laura wants to stay home, as she has a feeling Ritchie is coming down with a fever, and when they do eventually decide to go to the party, calamity befalls the babysitter, who hits her head. The party, in the meanwhile, provides an excellent opportunity for Van Dyke, Amsterdam, and Marie to show off, with Van Dyke highlighting his physical comedy, Amsterdam some one-liners, and Marie her killer Jimmy Durante impression with the song, “I Wish I Could Sing Like Durante”.

Morey Amsterdam, Rose Marie, and Dick Van Dyke in the Dick Van Dyke Show pilot, The Sick Boy and the Sitter

Rob and Laura return home before too long and discover the injured babysitter with her parents, but that Ritchie’s just fine, and the episode comes to a close. The chemistry between Van Dyke and Moore is playful and endearing and they’re the textbook definition of likeable and Amsterdam and Marie keep the show from becoming too saccharine. It’s a great balance and based on this episode alone, it’s easy to see how The Dick Van Dyke Show became such a hit and why it’s endured when most of the other comedies from this era have fallen by the wayside.

Kate Kulzick

This article is part of our month long theme dedicated to the greatest TV pilots.


Add Comment

10 Different Types of Financial Aid
Top 10 Richest American Idols
V-Moda Crossfade Wireless
The 5 Most Expensive Wireless Headphones: Ultimate Auditory Clarity
Business man watching business go bankrupt
25 Iconic Companies that Filed for Bankruptcy
7 Different Types of Roller Coasters
7 Surprising Physical and Mental Health Benefits of Playing Video Games
Females acting
7 Different Types of Acting Methods (Plus Acting Classes for Beginner Actors)
17 Different Types of Accordion
8 Different Types of Cantaloupes
5 Different Types of Maple Syrup
Pâté filled in a jar and spread on a toast
11 Different Types of Pate
16 Different Types of Apples
19 Different Types of Construction Vehicles
Fire Truck with Warm Yellow Lights
9 Different Types of Fire Trucks
22 Different Types of Forklifts for Indoor and Outdoor Work
17 Different Types of Trains
54 Different Types of Sports Played (Individual and Team Sports)
15 Different Types of Goggles
13 Different Types of Dumbbells
15 Awesome Alternatives to Skateboards (Plus Interesting Facts)
16 Different Types of Technology
man holding smartphone with vintage case
11 Types of Cell Phone Cases and Covers to Protect Your Expensive Smartphone
Black and Red Tablet Covers
8 Types of Tablet Cases for Kids, Protection, and Convenience
Camera, lenses and other photography equipments.
45 of the Best Online Camera Stores for the Perfect Pics