Survivor: One World Ep. 24.14, “Perception is Not Always Reality”: A surprisingly friendly jury rewards the legitimate winner

- Advertisement -

Survivor: One World Review, Season 24, Episode 14,
“Perception is Not Always Reality”
Airs Wednesdays at 8pm (ET) on CBS

There have been only a few cases where the Survivor winner has been telegraphed so far in advance. A recent example was Boston Rob’s roll through the Redemption Island season, but his edge as a four-time returning player made it easier. Kim has played front and center since the merge and put a huge target on her back. She’s walked the line between staying loyal to her alliance and removing major challengers. During the two-hour finale, she has several opportunities to take out players who could steal the prize. The surprising part is that she resists that temptation and sticks with Sabrina and Chelsea to face the music. Her confidence in the Final Tribal Council is clear, and the only remaining obstacle is bitterness from the jury.

Strong competitors from the past have assumed this powerful group would reward the most worthy player. It’s a big gamble to stick with nice people even if their games have been weaker. Winners like Natalie White and Bob Crowley are already fading from our memory after winning because they faced hated players. Kim earned a bunch of immunities and made big moves, but it’s her likability that earns her a 7-2 victory and the million-dollar prize. Jury members like Kat have been glaring nastily at Kim for weeks, so it’s refreshing to see most players take the high road. In fact, they take such a nice route that the composers use an excess of piano music to spotlight it. Kat does a complete about face and gives a passionate speech about her heart condition and getting the most out of life. Tarzan also fails to disappoint with a ridiculous monologue about his wife. They both shine, but the true champion is Jonas for mocking every ultra-serious juror in the show’s history with a fun joke about calling him “master”. Nicely played.

Heading into the Final Tribal Council, the others need strong plans to thwart Kim’s rise to Survivor greatness. Unfortunately, their performances play right into her hands. Here is a summary of each player’s approach to charming the Jury:

Chelsea: Instead of clarifying why she’s different than Kim, she admits that they worked together on everything. She also tries to combat the impression she’s cold-hearted.
Sabrina: She explains her lack of effort in challenges or strategy because it kept the target off her back. She lost her job recently, which makes this money essential.
Kim: She owns the strategic moves and talks about being willing to do anything to win, even if it means angering the people who leave.

It’s possible that Chelsea and Sabrina are doomed from the moment then enter the Final Tribal Council. However, neither truly goes for it and seems resigned to the fact that Kim is going to win. Their haphazard approach embodies the entire season and shows the superiority of the victor. One surprise from the questions is the perception that Chelsea is mean, with Christina even asking her why she hates people. This comes out of nowhere and is surprising given her edit for the season. The closest person to attack anyone is Troyzan, who asks Kim an inane question that could earn her a million dollars if she’s right. It’s clear that he’s not going to vote for her regardless, so it’s no surprise that he votes for Sabrina. Her other vote comes from Leif, who again seems way too nice to be on this show.

The two-hour episode begins with an exciting immunity challenge that incorporates several past contests into a fun combo. After untying ropes (again), cross a complicated maze, grab puzzles pieces, and then work to solve them to get three numbers. Chelsea and Alicia are extremely close, but Kim grabs immunity at the last minute. The deceptive editing suggests that Kim will flip on her pal Chelsea because she’s the biggest threat, which is the sensible move. Alicia seems confident she’s headed for the end, but Kim decides to stick with her alliance and boots her. Finally! This leaves Christina as the obvious goat to take to the finals. By winning the challenge, Kim avoids having to use her immunity idol at all. She wisely keeps that information secret to avoid grandstanding in front of the jury.

The final-four challenges have moved away from endurance and seem designed to deliver a more random result. This one requires serious concentration to keep from knocking down a stack of wooden bowls from the top of a tenuous structure. Kim grabs an early lead and receives a surprising test from Christina, but she never loses focus and takes the final win. It would have been interesting to see what the others would have done if Kim had lost. Instead, it comes down to keeping Christina or backstabbing an ally. It’s really easy to pick on Christina, who comes off terribly during her final day on the island. Jeff Probst and the entire jury spend Tribal Council looking down on her for giving up so easily. It fits with the way she’s played the entire game, so it seems fitting that she goes out with a whimper. It leads to pretty dull television, however. Thankfully, the Fallen Comrades walk returns before the challenge. Welcome back to a wonderfully cheesy delight!

Heading into the Final Tribal Council, the narrative is so direct that it feels like Kim must somehow lose the game. Sabrina gives a heartfelt confessional about her tough situation at home, which raises expectations that she might steal the crown. By taking fairly strong allies to the end, Kim risks making the error that Coach made last season by sticking with Albert and Sophie. The difference is her genuine likability, which leads to one of the more dominant performances in Survivor history.

Dan Heaton

2 Comments
  1. Dan Heaton says

    Dylan, I was surprised that Chelsea didn’t get voted out at the final five and thought she might get votes at the end. Watching the Final Tribal Council, however, it seemed pretty clear she wasn’t going to do well. Most people barely addressed her (besides Christina’s silly question), and she kept defending the impression she was cold-hearted. That was weird since we hadn’t really seen that side of her on the show. Something was missing in her edit, I guess.

    My wife gives me trouble for how much I like the Fallen Comrades part. It’s fun to see them struggle to find something to say about a lot of people (“he was tall”), especially the people who exited early. The silly drama of the whole thing is sort of endearing. Plus, it’s interesting to hear quick clips from each person about how they played.

  2. Dylan says

    “Thankfully, the Fallen Comrades walk returns before the challenge. Welcome back to a wonderfully cheesy delight!”

    Haha – the Walk of the Dead is what’s known as “an opportunity to fast-forward” in our house.

    This was a pretty friggin’ boring finale from start to finish. Kudos to Jonas, like you said, for providing the best laugh of the night. None of us want to see a clawless Jury but that’s what we got – a lot of niceties and kudos with some random comments here and there but nothing with teeth. Don’t get me wrong – I’m not a fan of Jury members showing up after having been out of the game for a week or more and acting oh-so-angry to the point where it feels manufactured, but shit, somebody had to feel jilted, right?

    Were you surprised to see Chelsea get totally shut out? We sure were – even if she wasn’t gonna win, I feel like she deserved a bit more credit than most people that don’t win. Seemed like she was Kim’s (pretty equal) partner from start to finish; she might not be as smooth a talker but her votes counted all the same.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.