The Cinematic Conflict Between East and West

- Advertisement -

Late last week, the production of the long-debated live action adaptation of Akira was again put on hold due to ‘budgetary and script differences’.  The decision wasn’t surprising – since Warner Bros. announced their intention to release a Westernised version of the beloved anime in 2002, Akira fans have vocalised their concerns and generally protested the idea.  The decision to cancel production ends years of development hell and a lot of debate amongst fans, but it is also something else.  It’s another adaptation saved from having its ‘plus-points’ being Westernised just for the sake of it.

It’s a cultural aspect that has bothered me for years.  Ever since the book Memoirs of a Geisha was remade by Chicago director Rob Marshall, it is a creative idea that I find quite infuriating.  I am a big fan of the book, so I was excited about news of its initial production.  Instead, the film featured established yet Chinese actresses and had the characters speaking English, yet the characters and story are based in Japan.  At the time, I saw it as a possible showcase for Japanese talent or a production that will be as immersive as the book.  However, as beautiful as the film ultimately became, I did not find myself absorbed in the story due to the certain aspects influenced by Westernised culture.


Another example is the 2006  Academy-Award winning drama The Departed by Martin Scorcese.  As an Asian, I love  the original film, Infernal  Affairs starring Andy Lau and  Tony Leung – a film so popular  in its native Hong Kong in  2002 that it had a prequel, as  well as a sequel, both released  in the following year.

So, why was there a need to re-develop it?

There seems to a cultural influence over the decision.
People do not want to read subtitles during a film and they want it to be in a ‘relatable’ location.  Most of the hidden gems of Eastern cinema have already been remade for the convenience of Western audiences – in terms of settings, dialogue and social references – this, in essence, deprives them of the essentially cultural experience that makes them so great.

The obvious reason for this is for movie studios to get on the bandwagon to quick cash, but to what cost? Film studios aim to make features that cinemagoers will enjoy. However, when film remakes are brought up in conversation, there will be viewers who do not realise that they are essentially watching a celluloid copy of something that is, in many filmgoer’s eyes, wonderful.
There are film fans that are faithful to original material and do not see the need for two films of the same premise.

What’s your opinion?  Thoughts on a postcard please…

– Katie Wong

10 Different Types of Financial Aid
Top 10 Richest American Idols
V-Moda Crossfade Wireless
The 5 Most Expensive Wireless Headphones: Ultimate Auditory Clarity
Business man watching business go bankrupt
25 Iconic Companies that Filed for Bankruptcy
20 Different Types of Balloons
12 Different Types of Tubas (Plus Interesting Facts)
Minivan loaded with beach stuff for day at the beach
The Ultimate Beach Checklist When Taking Young Kids to the Beach
Boy playing a trombone
10 Different Types of Trombones (Plus Fun Facts)
28 Different Types of Pineapple
20 Different Types of Limes
Table with a variety of nuts in bowls
20 Most Popular Types of Nuts (with Nutrition Fact Charts)
Bowl of cooked broccoli with walnuts
20 Types of Broccoli
Motorhome on highway going through Bryce Canyon in the USA
13 Types of RV’s (Recreational Vehicles) for All Kinds of Vacation Fun
Mechanic working on car in garage
10 Gift Ideas for Mechanics (Under $20, $50, $100 and $200)
A mechanic is repairing a car brake.
5 Different Types of Brake Pads and 6 Different Types of Brakes
9 Cool Minivan Alternatives
15 Awesome Alternatives to Skateboards (Plus Interesting Facts)
Baseball player hitting ball
10 Types of Baseball Bats that Rip the Leather Off the Ball
16 Types of Barbells for All Types of Lifts and Workouts
Basketball player slam dunking
29 Great Gift Ideas for Basketball Players (Under $20, $50, $100 and $200)
Inside a beautiful spa business
6 Capabilities the Best Spa Scheduling and Business Software Should Have
Ballet dancers in a dance studio
7 Features of the Best Dance Studio Business Software (Checklist)
Massage therapy clinic
7 Types of Massage Therapist Software for Growing the Business
10 Features the Best Hair Salon Scheduling Business Software Offer (Checklist)
Natural herbal vitamins.
10 of the Best Online Vitamin Stores